Jung's answer to job

Jung answered a number of questions about what he meant in the book, and those answers are published in volume 18s concerning answer to job. A commentary unravels jung s narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the book to which it refers, offering a comprehensive rereading of jung s text. In answer to job, jung demonstrates his indepth knowledge of the bible. The small book gripped him personally and, to a large extent, involuntarily. Jungs answer to job by cynthia avens my dear friend sally rhea, who is a member of our christosophia community, recently encouraged me to read carl jungs answer to job.

It is fascinating in answer to job how jung dances around the problem that by objective standards there is no external evidence for the historical existence of jesus christ, only literary claims. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. D here, he lays out how jung saw a profound change announcing itself in the collective subconscious of judaeochristian. The book places answer to job in the context of biblical commentary, and then examines the circumstances. Jungs answer to job by paul bishop, bishop paul, paperback. These had to do partly with the subject of selfdevelopment, represented in alchemical symbolism as the mysterium coniunctionis. Jung s reasoning for this is that everything comes from god including his dark son satan. Carl gustav jung full interview life widsom for all ages.

Job is a gentile man in the book of job of the hebrew bible. One of his best known works, the small volume is considered by many to be his most important and controversial work. Free download or read online answer to job pdf epub book. What god said to job 3839 1 that he is the creator and sustainer. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading answer to job. One would assume from the title that the text would be primarily about the book of job, but a great deal of jung s analysis extends through the entire old and new testaments, becoming something of a whirlwind biblical exegesis. This book offers an intellectual and cultural context for c. On the whole there are three publications which stand out from the work of c. Sep 06, 2018 timestamps included in the description. C g jungs answer to job a half century later by lewis. An original argument put across in a scholarly and accessible style provides an essential framework for understanding the work.

I was surprised by both the candor and the comprehensive sweep of the book. Oct 28, 2019 carl jung and excerpts from answer to job. My only regret is that i waited so long to get around. Of all faiths, christanity lends itself to the healing of the human psyche citation needed,in the unpublished letters. I knew that this was especially important since it had been on my reading list for the past few years. The book of job is a landmark in the long historical development of a divine drama.

A commentary by paul bishop 2002, paperback jung s answer to. The first edition of the novel was published in 1952, and was written by c. Answer to job is a very controversial book, but carl jung says the cold, hard truths about god and evil. Answer to job, first published in 1952, is jungs most extensive writing on a biblical text. Whilst remaining true to the tenets of analytical psychology, this commentary underlines answer to job. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 144 pages and is available in paperback format.

Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance. The story of job is probably the greatest existential. Jung s writing in answer to job is a personal process, and in part a dialogue, even an active imagination, with god via job. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jung s objectives in this text and offers a new way of reading the work. From covenants to consciousness in the book of job part 1. Considered one of jung s most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jung s most extensive commentary on a biblical text.

Exploring jungs answer to job an online course presented by rose f. Edward edinger on carl jungs answer to job and the. Here, he confronts the story of the man who challenged god, the man who experienced hell on earth and still did not reject his faith. Considered one of jungs most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jungs most extensive commentary on a biblical text.

Jung takes an acceptance of all things as they pertain to the psyche to be real and therefore do not need any further explanation or proof, but rather. Answer to job was first published in 1952 in german and was included in jungs collected works, as part of volume 11. This paperback edition of jungs classic work includes a new foreword by sonu shamdasani, philemon professor of jung history at university college london. One of the achievements of this remarkable and scholarly book is to illuminate jungs entire opus though its comprehensive attention to one of the most striking and distinctive of the collected works. Jung seems to identify with job s plight, and perhaps with job s presumably unconscious resentment, which must go unexpressed before god s omnipotence. The book places answer to job in the context of biblical commentary, and then examines the circumstances surrounding its compositions and immediate reception. Described by shamdasani as the theology behind the red book, answer to job examines the symbolic role that theological concepts play in an individuals psychic life. Indeed gods answer to job, far from being found in the yahweh speeches in job 3841, is found in christs cry of abandonment from the cross my god, my god, why hast thou forsaken me for this, jung maintains, is the moment in which god reaches full selfconsciousness, experiencing what job.

Gerhard wehr on carl jungs answer to job carl jung depth. There is a major contradiction within god, a shadow side to god. Described by shamdasani as the theology behind the red book, answer to job examines the symbolic role that theological concepts play in an individual s psychic life. My only regret is that i waited so long to get around to it. Greeted with controversy on its publication, answer to job has long been neglected by many serious commentators on jung. Nov 07, 2018 thanks, elaine, for your comment on the first job blog. He also enjoyed a friendship with an english roman catholic priest, father victor white, who corresponded with jung after he had published his controversial answer to job. The book is a quick read but it is very dense and insightful. Sep 01, 2019 sure jungs answer to job is worth reading as long as its read as jung attempting to make theological sense of his personal experience in broader context. Jung seems to identify with job s plight, and perhaps with job s presumably. It has been reported that during this illness a figure sat on his bedpost.

The main characters of this philosophy, psychology story are job. Jungs answer to job was first published in zurich in 1952 when he was 77 years old. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read answer to job. Whilst remaining true to the tenets of analytical psychology, this commentary underlines answer to job s greater significance in terms of cultural history. Jung has never pursued the psychology of religion apart from gener. Jungs authentic response the book of job has inspired many interpretations and commentaries. Jung s answer to job was recommended to me by friends, and after some procrastination, i finally decided to give it a read.

Jungs answer to job was officially published in english in late 1954, but even before that white had to deal with the impression it left on jungs readers from other editions. This is not a scientific book but a personal confrontation with the traditional christian world view, occasioned by the impact of the new dogma of the assumption. Jung jung extracts with a new foreword by sonu shamdasani by jung, c. Answer to job quotes showing 17 of 7 the difference between the natural individuation process, which runs its course unconsciously, and the one which is consciously realized, is tremendous. But when god speaks, it is not with answers and explanations, but with a whole series of questions 38. Jung perceived in the hidden recesses of the human psyche the cause of a crisis that plagues modern humanity and leaves the individual, like job, isolated and bewildered in the face of impenetrable fortune. I cant even imagine trying to read it if i hadnt been actively grappling with some of his concepts already, having just read modern man in search of a. Publication date 1954 topics bible, bible, philosophy, religion. Jungs answer to job ebook by paul bishop rakuten kobo.

I had been studying existentialism for a few months when i happened upon carl jungs answer to job. Answer to job is my first carl jung book, i am looking forward to reading more of jung. In answer to job, jung examines gods malevolent side or, in jungian terminology, his shadow, with the book of job as a launching point. Carl jung depth psychology reading group 285 views. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jung s objectives in this text and offers a new way of read this book offers an intellectual and cultural context for c. November 9th, 2009 through december 14th, 2009 the book does not pretend to be. Dec 10, 2019 this is known in jungian circles as edinger s famous job interview. Considered one of jungs most controversial works, answer to job also stands as jungs most extensive commentary on a.

Please improve it by verifying the claims made and adding inline citations. Bishop by commentary a paul paul a commentary answer. If there is anything like the spirit seizing one by the scruff of the neck, it was the way this book answer to job came into being. Father victor white challenged jungs answer to job, and a number of letters were written one to the other. Jungs answer to job was recommended to me by friends, and after some procrastination, i finally decided to give it a read. I sometimes hear the phrase the patience of job but, until reading this book, i was unaware of the story that gives rise to this. Indeed gods answer to job, far from being found in the yahweh speeches in job 3841, is found in christs cry of abandonment from the cross my god, my god, why hast thou forsaken me for this, jung maintains, is the moment in which god reaches full selfconsciousness, experiencing what job and humanity experience.

Apply to ausbildung fachinformatiker anwendungsentwicklung, safety officer, bookkeeper and more. Reading jung s answer to job enlivened an otherwise boring day for me. In his 1952 answer to job essay, so controversial that jung himself called it pure poison, jung criticizes the early sadistic nature of god found so completely in the old testaments book of job. Jung delayed writing the piece because he knew it would be so controversial. One of the achievements of this remarkable and scholarly book is to illuminate jungs. It came upon me suddenly and unexpectedly during a feverish illness. Carl jung wrote his response as an answer to job jung. The theme throughout the first half of answer to job relates primarily to the story of job. At the time the book was written, there were already many testimonies which had given a contradictory picture of yahwehthe picture of a god who knew no moderation in his emotions and suffered precisely from this lack of moderation.

It is regarded as one of jungs most controversial works. In his answer to job, carl gustav jung, examines the divine drama of the christ child. Dec 02, 2009 in recent years i have come across many references to the book answer to job, by c. Answer to job was jungs moby dick, his great whale.

Jung s answer to job unravels jung s narrative, offering a comprehensive rereading of jung s text, as well as a repositioning in its cultural context. God wanted to become man and still wants to carl jung, cw 11, answer to job, page 455. Bishop paperback job by jung s to 2002, the answer of jesus to job by g. He even, in a characteristic moment of imaginative genius, tried to be the therapist of the judeochristian god, in his iconoclastic book answer to job. Described by shamdasani as the theology behind the red book, answer to job. Rather than an attitude of submission, he argues more for a sort of cocreation, recognising that the human psyche has. By these questions, and their implied answers, he teaches job. This paperback edition of jung s classic work includes a new foreword by sonu shamdasani, philemon professor of jung history at university college london. Read jung s answer to job a commentary by paul bishop available from rakuten kobo. A commentary, the author argues that such neglect is due to a failure to understand jungs objectives in this text and offers a new way of reading the work.

We use cookies to offer you a better experience, personalize content, tailor advertising, provide social media features, and better understand the use of our services. Carl jung wrote his response as an answer to job jung, 1952, which he wrote in one burst of energy during an illness. God also contains omniscience of the outcome that will happen if he lets satan have his way with job and yet god does not consult his omniscience and turns a blind eye to the pain job suffers. A commentary unravels jung s narrative by reading it in the chronological order of the biblical events it analyses and the book to which it refers, offering a comprehensive rereading of jung. Jung s answer to job by cynthia avens my dear friend sally rhea, who is a member of our christosophia community, recently encouraged me to read carl jungs answer to job. One of the things i love about carl jung is the fact that he was a deep philosophical thinker who examined all aspects of the self when writing about the human experience. Initially greeted with controversy, answer to jobhas been neglected by many serious commentators on jung. Jung says, job must let go of his right to expect that god.